Raise your hand if you loooove a good slide of pie: 🙋♀️ Overland Park boasts some of the best pie spots around, offering both sweet, dessert pies, and savory, pizza pies. Each destination brings its own unique twist to these beloved classics, promising a culinary adventure like no other. Let’s take a delicious journey through some of the top picks in town.
- Mo Pie (Various locations)
Meet Curt, the mastermind behind Mo Pie. With over two decades of experience as the vice president of Tippin’s, Curt knows his pies inside out. After watching the industry’s shift towards automation and lower-quality ingredients, he decided to take matters into his own hands. Thus, Mo Pie was born.
What sets Mo Pie apart is its commitment to traditional flavors alongside super fun creations. From classic apple and pumpkin to mouthwatering options like red berry rhubarb and white chocolate strawberry cream, there’s something to suit every palate. I had the privilege of peeking behind the scenes at their pie-making process, and let me just say: it’s pure magic.
I left with a trio of delights: Red Hot Apple Pie (reportedly Andy Reid’s favorite), chocolate strawberry silk, and their top seller and my personal favorite, key lime. With a whopping 47 varieties to choose from, you’re sure to find your perfect slice of heaven. Order online at mopieco.com or swing by Fairway Markets or the Overland Park Farmers Market to get your fix.
2. Mud Pie Vegan Bakery & Coffee ( 7319 W 95th St, Overland Park)
For those with dietary preferences or restrictions, Mud Pie Vegan Bakery & Coffee is a dream come true. This cozy family-owned business specializes in handcrafted vegan treats that are sure to delight even the most discerning of palates. Whether you’re a committed vegan or just looking to expand your dessert horizons, Mud Pie has something for everyone.
Their menu features an array of tempting pies on special occasions, from classic French silk to seasonal favorites like pumpkin pie. Each treat is made fresh daily using quality ingredients, ensuring every bite is a moment of pure indulgence.
3. Fat Sully’s (7101 W 80th St, Overland Park)
Sometimes, you just need to go big or go home. And that’s exactly what you’ll find at Fat Sully’s. This bustling joint is known for its larger-than-life slices of NY-style pizza, towering double patty smash burgers, and decadent fried chicken sandwiches.
Their pizza pies are no joke—they’re huge! Whether you’re dining with a group and opting for their monstrous 26-inch pizza or flying solo like me, their “big ass slices” will surely impress.
Pro tip: Come hungry—trust me, you’ll need both hands for this feast!
So whether you’re craving a classic slice of pie, exploring vegan delicacies, or indulging in larger-than-life eats, Overland Park has you covered. Dive into these top pie spots and treat yourself to a culinary experience that’s nothing short of divine.
Have I missed any of your favorite pie shops? Chime in below and let me know!
Mariah Haberman
Mariah Haberman is a travel writer and content creator based in Kansas City. She explores the very best of the Midwest on her blog, Life with Mariah. Follow her on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok.
